Blog Team

How to have a performance conversation with an employee

When a problem needs a direct conversation and how to prepare for it, run it and follow it through.

Something is off. An employee keeps missing deadlines, or their work needs constant correction, or they are affecting the crew in ways that are hard to measure and easy to feel. The owner notices. They tell themselves it will improve. It does not. Weeks pass and the problem grows. Eventually something forces the issue: a customer complaint, a blow-up on the team, a good employee who quits. Now the owner is handling a crisis where a conversation would have done.

The hard conversation avoided for three months would have taken fifteen minutes. The crisis that replaced it takes a lot longer.

What avoidance costs

Avoiding the conversation is a decision, and it has consequences.

For the employee, silence says the behaviour is acceptable. If it were a problem, someone would say so. The absence of feedback sends a message, and it is usually the wrong one.

For the rest of the team, an unaddressed problem says the standards are optional. It says the rules apply differently to different people, and that management either has not noticed or will not act. Both readings wear down trust and effort across the whole team.

For the business, the cost builds week by week. Work that needs redoing. Customers who get inconsistent service. An owner or supervisor who spends their time working around a person when they should be working with them.

Waiting fixes none of it. Regular check-ins are the earliest warning system, the point where small problems show up before they need a hard conversation. Once a pattern has formed, a more direct conversation is due.

How to know a conversation is needed

A one-off mistake, a rough week or a normal dip in performance can be handled in the moment with a quick, direct word, and then you move on.

A conversation is needed when the behaviour keeps happening, when it affects quality, customers or the team, or when you have already given feedback in the moment and nothing has changed.

A useful test: if this carries on for another month at the current level, will it still be a problem? If yes, the conversation is overdue.

Many performance problems are expectations problems

Before you have the conversation, ask one question: does the employee know what you expect?

A lot of what looks like poor performance is a gap between what the owner thinks is obvious and what the employee understands the job to be. An employee who never follows up on quotes may be doing exactly what they were told. Nobody may have said that follow-up is part of the role, how quickly it should happen or how many times.

If the expectation was never stated, the conversation is about making it clear. That is a different and much easier talk than correcting a failure. If expectations were never set properly, start there.

If the expectation was clear and has not been met, it is time for the performance conversation.

A simple framework for raising a performance issue

Before the conversation: prepare with specifics

  • Write down two or three specific examples of the behaviour or work you want to address. Use observable incidents the employee will recognize, and leave out general impressions.
  • Decide what outcome you want. Make it a specific, observable change, with a date and a standard.
  • Pick the setting: in private, at a time when neither of you is in the middle of something urgent.

In the conversation: open directly, then listen

  • Skip the long warm-up. "I want to talk with you about something specific, and I want to be straight with you about it."
  • State the issue with examples. "Over the last three weeks I have noticed X. Specifically, [example 1] and [example 2]. This is a problem because [effect on customers, the team or the business]."
  • Let them respond, and listen properly. Sometimes there is context you do not have: a misunderstanding about the process, a missing tool, something going on at home. Take it seriously before you decide what comes next.
  • Be plain about what needs to change. "From here on, I need [specific behaviour] by [date or standard]. This one is a requirement."
  • Agree on a follow-up. "Let's check in on this in two weeks." Setting the date shows you are serious.

After the conversation: write it down and follow through

  • Record it briefly: the date, the issue, the agreed change and the follow-up date. A short note in a file is enough. It matters if the situation escalates.
  • Hold the follow-up. This is where owners fall down most. The conversation happens, things improve for a bit, and the follow-up gets skipped because things seem better. The follow-up checks whether the issue is fixed, and it also shows you meant what you said.

Follow-ups slip when they live in your head. In the systems we build, an agreed change becomes an action with an owner and a date, and it comes back up at the next check-in. See meetings and action items.

When one conversation is not enough

Some problems carry on after one conversation, or two. The issue continues despite clear feedback and agreed changes.

At this point the process becomes more formal. You move to a documented improvement plan: specific expectations, a defined timeframe and a plain statement of what happens if the change does not happen.

This is honest, and it is fair. The employee deserves to know exactly where they stand and what continued poor performance will lead to. Written records of when issues were raised and what was expected protect both of you. Without them, it is hard to show the employee was told and given a chance to improve.

Your quarterly reviews are the natural place to track an ongoing issue over time. The same format each quarter lets you revisit agreed changes and keep a written record.

Get advice before formal action. Employment law differs between Canada and the US, and by province and state. In most of Canada, letting someone go without cause still requires notice or pay in lieu, and poor performance alone rarely meets the legal bar for cause. In most US states employment is at will, but a dismissal can still be challenged, for example as discrimination or retaliation, and your records will matter. Talk to an employment lawyer or HR professional before you start a formal disciplinary process or a termination.

The hard conversation is almost always easier than the one it prevents. Performance problems do not fix themselves. An employee who is struggling deserves to know it. The team watching how you handle it deserves to see that the standards are real.

Next step

If feedback, follow-ups and review notes are scattered across notebooks and texts, they are hard to rely on when you need them. We build connected systems that keep them with the rest of your operations. Book a free 30-minute call to talk it through.

360° · TRUE NORTH

Want this built into how you work?

Tell us how your business runs today. In 30 minutes you'll know what a connected system would change.

Book a free 30-minute call